CURMUDGUCATION blog: Thoughts on Homework and Flipping Classrooms — is this REALLY good for students?

Homework and Flipping

Posted: 16 Dec 2015 08:35 AM PST

It was an odd juxtaposition. There on my twitter feed, side by side, a link to an article arguing against homework, and a link to an argument favoring the flipped classroom.

The arguments against homework are many– as many as there are different types of homework. Students don’t really benefit from it. Students don’t really do it. And those are just educator arguments– my students will also argue that after they leave the school building, that time is their time, for work, for family, for whatever pursuits they choose to pursue. That’s the point of view that leads commenters to say that homework is bad for the whole child.

And yet what is a flipped classroom except a classroom that runs on huge amounts of homework.

I have no strong feelings about the flipped classroom– I’ve been doing it my whole career, only instead of saying “Go home and watch this video,” I’ve been saying “Go home and read this book.” I don’t do a lot of traditional homework beyond some occasionally “Go forth and practice this skill on your own.” But my honors students in particular are expected to do the readings and write the papers primarily on their own time.

I read teachers who have success flipping, and I have encountered the following conversation among students many times as well:

Chris: Did you watch that video last night?

Pat: Nah. He’s just going to have to explain it all in class anyway.

I have found technology useful for extending the classroom. Back when my school district still used Moodle, I could run entire units as on-line segments, which made a nice way to compensate for the class time that I was losing. This year I have a class of students who are required to blog, sometimes on prompts related to classwork, sometimes to other prompts, and always on other topics of their own choosing. And I’ve found on-line elements can be a good way to do units that involve “Go figure out what this is and then explain it to me in your own words with either created or found examples” (e.g. logical fallacies). Those then become part of the tool box that I expect them to be able to use in class work.

So am I good teacher because I’m using technology to extend the learning experience beyond the temporal and physical boundaries of my classroom, or am I terrible teacher because I still give homework?

For the rest of the story goe here: CURMUDGUCATION: Homework and Flipping

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s